Maybe next season we will give it a shot again and then we can chat about it :) It's been a while, so I don't remember exactly what our complaints were, but one thing I remember is that they would often have these ridiculous abstract themes... and then they'd either pick the best ones regardless of how well they applied to the theme, or they'd do the complete opposite and pick the ONLY one that did something related to the theme, regardless of how good it was.

And their gripes often seemed to be about things that we felt were absurdly trivial. Like one season they sent a guy home because every time he did a character he had what they felt was the same nose. Yeah, okay, let's just completely ignore EVERYTHING ELSE and focus on his nose.

But it might just be a problem I have with panel-judging shows lol. I'm the same way with Design Star. I absolutely LOATHE one of the judges and I have stopped watching the show because of it. Even though interior design is my ~thing.~ He has no imagination whatsoever and can't see outside his own box of what he considers good design to be. It's infuriating.